Discover the bestselling BillyOh Fraya Log Cabin

Should I Repair or Replace My Shed?

Last updated: December 15, 2025

Your shed has served you for years, but now it’s showing signs of wear. Some fixes might be enough to keep it going, but others are past their best. We’re going to go through some FAQs to check your shed and decide if repair is necessary or it’s time to let it go.

[spcacer height=”20px”]

How Do I Know if My Shed Needs Repair?

[spcacer height=”20px”]

You’ll know it needs repair when the problems are limited to small, isolated areas. For instance, a panel is loose, there’s a small leak, or a tiny patch or a spot of rot shows up.

[spcacer height=”20px”]

Might as well take the time to walk around and check the floorboards. Look for wobbling panels or hinges that need tightening. These minor issues are exactly what repairs are for.

[spcacer height=”20px”]

Overall, the structure itself is still mostly sound and can be fixed.

[spcacer height=”20px”]

When Should I Replace My Shed?

[spcacer height=”20px”]

Replace it when the damage goes beyond a few small spots and begins to affect its safety and stability. Give the floor and walls a poke; if the floor sags or the shed shakes, it’s past the point of easy fixes. Repairs will just keep costing you. It’s also cheaper and safer to get a new one if rot or decay has spread across large sections of the shed (multiple walls, the floor and parts of the frame).

[spcacer height=”20px”]

The best way to prevent these issues is through a solid maintenance routine. Check out our guide to waterproofing your wooden shed.

[spcacer height=”20px”]

Replacing the shed also gives you a chance to upgrade. You could get a garden storage with better cladding or slightly bigger to make better use of your space.

[spcacer height=”20px”]

How to Dispose of an Old Shed

[spcacer height=”20px”]

Are Some Shed Materials Harder to Repair?

[spcacer height=”20px”]

Yes, and this is especially true for metal and plastic sheds. For one, the panels are more difficult to replace, not to mention that it’s not always simple to patch up holes or gaps. Small dents or holes often need special tools or kits, and sometimes repairs don’t last.

[spcacer height=”20px”]

But if you have a guide like this, you can make it work:

[spcacer height=”20px”]
ScenarioApproximate Cost (UK)
Major repair (lots of rot, floor issues, multiple boards)~£200 – £600+ (depending on what needs fixing)
New small kit shed (budget)~From around £420+ (e.g. BillyOh Switch Overlap Pent Shed)
[spcacer height=”20px”]

Wooden sheds, in contrast, are simpler to work with. A loose board, a small patch of rot, or a minor leak can often be fixed with basic tools and a bit of know-how.

[spcacer height=”20px”]

How Do I Compare the Cost of Repairing vs Getting a New Shed?

[spcacer height=”20px”]

Come up with the list of needs to be fixed first, e.g. the boards, floors, roof, or doors. Then, figure out roughly what it will cost for materials, tools, or someone to do it for you. Now look at what a new shed costs and compare.

[spcacer height=”20px”]

To give you an idea, here’s a cost comparison:

[spcacer height=”20px”]

If the repairs are creeping close to that, getting a new one makes more sense.

[spcacer height=”20px”]

What Kinds of Upgrades Could I Get if I Get a New Shed?

[spcacer height=”20px”]

With a new shed, you can make it suit how you use it. Maybe you go a bit bigger so there’s room to move around, or a lean-to shed or narrow shed if you’re limited in space. Or finally invest in a pressure treated shed or tongue and groove shed so it lasts longer.

[spcacer height=”20px”]

Our range of garden sheds comes in different sizes, roof styles, and cladding to suit various needs. Refer to our guide to get started:

[spcacer height=”20px”]

Garden Sheds Buying Guide