Plastic Sheds vs. Vinyl Sheds: What’s the Difference?

In the world of garden storage solutions, plastic and vinyl sheds have risen to fame. But which of the two should you go for?

Choosing the right material is crucial, impacting both functionality and aesthetics. This will delve into the key distinctions of each, helping you make an informed choice. Read on!

Material Composition

Lifetime 15ftx8ft Heavy Duty Single Entrance Plastic Shed
Lifetime 15ftx8ft Heavy Duty Single Entrance Plastic Shed

Plastic sheds are typically constructed from high-density polyethene (HDPE) or polyvinyl chloride (PVC). These materials offer several key advantages as garden shed materials.

First, plastic is lightweight. As an outdoor structure, this feature makes it easy to assemble and relocate. This element is also resistant to rust, rot, and corrosion. It ensures longevity without the need for frequent maintenance in turn.

Plastic garden sheds excel in various weather conditions. From heavy rain to intense sunlight, you name it. All thanks to their inherent water resistance and UV protection. This durability makes them a reliable choice for year-round outdoor storage.

Vinyl Shed Construction

Saffron Apex Plus 10.5x8ft Vinyl Shed
Saffron Apex Plus 10.5x8ft Vinyl Shed

Vinyl sheds are constructed primarily from polyvinyl chloride (PVC). Such a material boasts durability and resilience. PVC’s inherent properties make it a popular choice for outdoor storage.

Vinyl is known for its exceptional moisture resistance. This makes the composition impervious to rot, rust, and termite damage. This water-resistant quality also ensures a long lifespan with minimal maintenance requirements. For one, vinyl sheds like the Saffron Apex Extra do not need painting and are easy to clean.

This makes vinyl sheds a wise investment for those seeking low-maintenance, lasting storage.

Aesthetics and Designs

Lifetime 20ft x 8ft Heavy Duty Dual Entrance Plastic Shed
Lifetime 20ft x 8ft Heavy Duty Dual Entrance Plastic Shed

The aesthetic appeal of plastic and vinyl sheds differs significantly. Plastic storage sheds often exhibit a utilitarian appearance with a straightforward, functional design. While they come in various colours, customisation options may be limited.

Meanwhile, vinyl models offer a more visually appealing option. They resemble traditional wooden sheds and come in a range of attractive colours. What’s more, they can mimic the look of wood grain and often feature decorative elements, e.g., shutters. This, overall, shows vinyl sheds to be more aesthetically pleasing and customisable.

Maintenance Requirements

Saffron Lean-To 4ft×8ft Vinyl Shed Including Foundation Kit
Saffron Lean-To 4ft×8ft Vinyl Shed Including Foundation Kit

Maintenance needs for plastic and vinyl garden buildings differ:

Plastic sheds for sale are relatively low-maintenance. They require occasional cleaning with soapy water to remove dirt and debris. They may fade over time due to UV exposure, but repainting isn’t necessary. However, securing against strong winds is important.

Vinyl sheds share the low-maintenance advantage but have a slight edge. Regular cleaning with a garden hose and mild detergent keeps them looking fresh. Unlike plastic, vinyl doesn’t fade significantly and retains its colour vibrancy. Additionally, its sturdier construction often makes it more wind-resistant. This feature reduces the need for extra anchoring.

In terms of who needs less effort to maintain appearance and durability, vinyl wins.

Cost Considerations

Cost considerations between plastic and vinyl sheds are as follows:

Initial investment

BillyOh Ashford Apex Plastic Garden Storage Shed Including Foundation Kit Grey
BillyOh Ashford Apex Plastic Garden Storage Shed Including Foundation Kit Grey

Plastic sheds, such as the BillyOh Ashford, are generally more budget-friendly upfront. This, in return, makes them an attractive choice for cost-conscious buyers. In contrast, vinyl models tend to have a higher initial price point. But this is often due to their aesthetic appeal and sturdier construction.

Long-term savings

Vinyl sheds may offer better long-term value. Their durability often means fewer repair or replacement costs over time. They also tend to retain their appearance, reducing the need for refurbishing.

Installation costs

Both shed types often come with DIY-friendly assembly options. But generally, professional installation can add to the cost. Vinyl structures, given their larger size and weight, may incur higher installation expenses.

Potential repairs

Plastic storage may require more frequent repairs due to its lightweight construction. Vinyl sheds, being more robust, typically have fewer repair needs. This can lead to potential savings in maintenance and replacement expenses.

Environmental Impact

Saffron Apex Extra 15x8ft Vinyl Shed
Saffron Apex Extra 15x8ft Vinyl Shed

Environmental considerations for plastic and vinyl sheds are as follows:


Plastic sheds are often made from recyclable materials like HDPE or PVC. Recycling them after their lifespan reduces their environmental impact. However, their production does involve the use of petroleum-based materials.


Vinyl sheds can be environmentally friendly when made from sustainably sourced vinyl. Look for certifications like “GreenGuard” or “LEED” to ensure eco-friendly options. They tend to be more energy-efficient once installed due to their insulation properties.

Sustainability concerns

Both materials have sustainability challenges. Plastics contribute to waste issues, and vinyl production potentially emits harmful chemicals. Buyers should consider the overall environmental footprint. This includes material sourcing and disposal when making their choice.


The choice between plastic and vinyl sheds hinges on your priorities. Plastic offers affordability and minimal maintenance. Whereas vinyl excels in aesthetics and long-term durability. Consider your budget, design preferences, and environmental concerns when deciding. Whichever material you choose, both offer functional storage solutions for your outdoor space!

For more storage options, Browse through Garden Buildings Direct. We offer various materials and styles, such as metal sheds and tongue and groove sheds.

Here’s your next read: Do Plastic Sheds Need a Base?